A Marriott Residence Inn guest's 2024 Subaru Outback suffered $15,000 in damage while in the hotel's valet care last month at the Los Angeles LIVE property. The guest discovered the damage themselves without any notification from the hotel. When they reported the incident, the hotel offered a free drink and told them to have the car towed away. Follow-up attempts with Marriott produced no additional assistance.

The hotel charges $62 to $82 per day for valet parking, according to its website. The guest received no ride, room compensation, or apology.

Under California law, a paid custodian like a valet service must exercise ordinary care with entrusted property. Hotels are not automatically immune from liability simply because a valet works for a contractor. A "not responsible" clause on a parking claim ticket does not end a guest's claim. California imposes specific requirements for printed parking contracts that attempt to limit liability.

Guests facing similar situations should notify their insurance company promptly. Collision coverage can pay for repairs minus the deductible. Actual losses can include repair costs, reasonable towing and storage fees, and loss of use during the repair period. California's small claims court limit for individuals is $12,500.

A contrasting example occurred at the Jefferson Hotel in Richmond, where a valet caused door damage. A manager reviewed the damage, accepted responsibility, and sent a repair check for $175. That same stay included other service failures, and the assistant general manager offered future complimentary nights and dinner, prompting the guest to return.