American Airlines operates more passengers and flights than Delta or United, yet lags significantly in profitability. Delta Air Lines earned $5.1 billion in profits last year while United made $3.3 billion. American earned just $111 million, and is on track to lose money this year.
The financial gap reflects in stock performance. American's shares are down more than 50% from their 2019 high. Since November 2023, Delta and United shares have more than tripled, while American's are up less than 30%.
Missteps have contributed to American's weaker standing. The airline scrapped seatback screens on domestic narrowbodies and maintains a weaker international network compared to rivals. These decisions have hurt profitability relative to competitors.
The disparity extends to employee compensation. Delta set aside $1.3 billion in profit sharing for 2025. American is attempting to close the gap through various changes, including new routes, premium offerings, and other adjustments.