American Airlines did not respond to a Department of Transportation complaint deadline set for November 13, according to a travel journalist who challenged the airline's cancellation of award tickets booked for his family.

The journalist had booked multi-city award tickets using American Airlines' AAdvantage program at discounted rates during a pricing error lasting several weeks. American discovered the mistake and canceled the tickets about two weeks after issuing them, roughly two weeks after discovery.

American's own Contract of Carriage sets a 72-hour window from discovery to cancel mistake fares. The airline took approximately two weeks to cancel after identifying the error, exceeding its own deadline.

The journalist filed a Department of Transportation complaint arguing American violated its own published terms. American responded that AAdvantage terms give them the right to correct mistakes and that consumers have no private right of action against airlines. The journalist replied that American's own AAdvantage Terms state that conflicts are resolved in favor of the Conditions of Carriage and International Tariff, both of which specify the 72-hour deadline.

American did not submit a rebuttal response by the November 13 deadline set by the Department. The journalist speculates American may have had offline conversations with DOT to argue against commencing enforcement action, allowed under regulations prior to formal enforcement proceedings.

The journalist notes that the Department of Transportation has in past cases, including Gurevich v. Alitalia, treated misleading contractual protections as unfair and deceptive practices. He adds that he expects DOT will ultimately need to either pursue enforcement or explain why it will not, though no timeframe requires such action.