American Airlines collected a $75 expedite fee for award bookings made within 21 days of departure long after the process became fully automated, according to Maya Leibman, the airline's former AAdvantage loyalty program chief. Leibman revealed on the Airlines Confidential podcast this week that the airline kept charging the fee even though the justification for it, manual processing by agents, no longer applied. The airline finally removed the $75 charge in January 2020. Elite frequent flyers had the fee waived.

American once attempted a more aggressive move. In May 2008 the airline announced a $5 fee for award bookings made on its website, extending charges to the cheaper booking channel. The airline never implemented that fee and backed away without a public announcement.

Leibman defended checked bag fees by noting that people and equipment are involved in moving luggage, but acknowledged the award booking fee as indefensible once the process automated. The close-in award fee survived its own logic until dropped three years ago.