Former Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost noticed something that seemed suspicious: his flight to Washington's National Airport still takes about 50 minutes, but the published schedule has grown to an hour and 42 minutes. He concluded that airlines must be padding schedules to artificially boost their on-time statistics. It's a theory that sounds plausible on the surface—and it's wrong. The real story is far more complicated, and far less nefarious, than Yost's explanation suggests.
Yes, the government counts an arrival as on time when the plane reaches the gate less than 15 minutes after its scheduled arrival time, so longer schedules do provide a buffer. But airlines pay for those extra minutes, and that's expensive. Southwest Airlines estimated back in 2015 that adding just a couple of minutes of block time across its entire schedule would cost the equivalent of 8 to 10 airplanes' daily flying. This isn't a cost-free way to manipulate statistics—it's a genuine operational expense. If airlines were simply trying to game the system, there would be far cheaper ways to do it.
The real culprit is unpredictability in air travel, much of it beyond any single airline's control. National Airport itself is instructive. The FAA reduced the airport's hourly arrival rate from 36 to 26 after the January 2025 collision, later increasing it to 30. When capacity is that constrained, when controller shortages and equipment problems persist, and when demand concentrates into busy periods, airlines need schedules that work in normal conditions—not just on ideal days when planes zoom straight to the runway. If variability in travel time grows, the schedule must grow with it.
There's also the matter of how airports actually operate. A plane can land early but still reach the terminal around the originally scheduled time because its assigned gate may still have another airplane at it. As American's former chief explained in 2018, hubs use essentially all their gate capacity at peak times. An early landing doesn't help if there's nowhere to go. In these conditions, building realistic expectations into schedules isn't cooking the books—it's acknowledging how air travel actually works.
When American redesigned its Dallas operation in April, moving from 9 large connecting waves to 13 smaller ones alongside longer block times, missed connections dropped 50 percent. That's not statistical manipulation; that's operational improvement. The real solution to flight reliability isn't tightening schedules and hoping for the best. It's improving the underlying system through more airport capacity and better air traffic control. Until then, expecting airlines to promise 50-minute flights when conditions often don't allow it is asking them to set themselves up for failure.