Christopher Nienhuis rented a Buick at Milwaukee airport through Sixt in October and received a $1,589 damage bill days later for black splatter around the license plate and scuffing near the rear windshield. He disputed the charges, saying he did not cause the damage and that some of it could be washed off. The bill included nearly $500 in illegal fees under Wisconsin law, which prohibits loss of use charges, administrative fees, appraisal fees, and diminished value charges.
Sixt dropped the claim a week after a news reporter contacted the company. Four customers with disputed claims from the same Milwaukee airport location all had their claims withdrawn.
Wisconsin law limits damage liability to reasonable repair costs reflecting the rental company's available discounts, or the vehicle's value before damage, whichever is lower. Nienhuis disputed the claim and complained to consumer agencies, but says it went to collections anyway before the company withdrew it.
Sixt's 2025 damage billing settlement addressed allegations involving estimated repairs, diminished value, loss of use and administrative charges. The package totaled $11 million, including about $2.87 million in potential refunds and $6.6 million in abandoned collection claims, plus legal and administrative costs.
Milwaukee airport's lease with Sixt requires the company to follow the law and allows termination for an uncured violation after notice. The airport said it was waiting for the state consumer protection agency to determine whether a violation occurred. It is not yet clear whether Sixt has stopped charging these fees in Wisconsin.